dinsdag 30 augustus 2011

Granados, Turina, Guridi, Montsalvatge: Canciones Espanolas

It's been a long while since I have listened to vinyl, but as I am only messing a little bit around, without, for the time being, a fixed listening perimeter in mind, I picked up this attractively 1970s specimen from a 'KM-treated' box. It stayed in my mind after JD had played a few tracks when I picked up the LP after the cleaning treatment. (I also think Pristine's newsletter with a report on Andrew Rose's visit to the Albeniz museum has something to do with my Spanish leanings). After careful listening I can indeed confirm that it is a marvel of a recording. The good news is that I picked up for 1 euro from the bargain bin in a Brussels second hand vinyl shop ...

The repertoire was all but unknown to me. A series of Spanish songs from composers I mostly hadn't heard about. Granados, certainly, but Montsalvatge, Guridi, and even Turina didn't ring much of a bell. The first side starts with a collection of three older songs - from the 16th to 18th century - where the lute accompaniment has been transcribed for piano. Beautiful, noble songs, drenched in that characteristic Iberian idiom. Granados fills the remainder of this LP side with 6 tonadillas. This is serious music, almost Mahlerian in its mixture of folksiness and expressionistic anguish. Side two continues with three colourful, masterfully impressionistic Turina songs, of which the darkly shaded El Fantasma stands out. Then three lively songs by Basque composer Jesus Guridi (who was cosmopolitan enough to write Seis canciones castellanas). The lines are more clearly etched here compared to the Turina.

Let us pause for a minute and ask who Jesus Guridi was anyway? Wikipedia learns that he lived a long (1886-1961) and fairly prolific life and was known as 'the' Basque composer during his lifetime. Interestingly he spent two years in Brussels studying with Joseph Jongen. His output covers both instrumental and vocal music (notably famous zarzuela) and is well represented in the Naxos catalogue. There is a 1946 Sinfonia Pyrenaica which sounds superbly colourful and accomplished and is going straight on my list of 'to buy'! Now I'd like to find his Homenaje a Walt Disney for piano and orchestra (there's a recording on the Claves label, now deleted, that can be found used).

The recital ends with a delightful collection of 6 Canciones Negras by Xavier Montsalvatge. Here Antillian echoes abound. The Cancion de cuna para dormir a un negrito is a truly delightful lullaby and seems to be a fixture in Spanish female singers' repertoires. The final song Canto Negro is a funny and virtuoso finale to a superbly entertaining recital.

What pulls this collection to an altogether stratospheric level is the very special voice of Teresa Berganza. She was 40 when the recital was taped in 1975 and at the peak of her career. It was two years later that she sang the title role in the still famous Carmen taped by DGG under Abbado. Admittedly not everyone is equally enamoured by the rather patrician slant she gives to the role. But that she was a singer of impeccably cultured artistry is undeniable. Here, on this LP, it is difficult to imagine more accomplished renderings of these songs. They just sound perfect, the voice being in total command. It's a masterful blend between intellectualism, poetry and visceral passion. The singer is marvelously accompanied by Felix Lavilla, who happened to be her husband for 20 years and fathered Berganza's three children. However, they divorced just two years after this recording and it looks like this wasn't a happy marriage at all (Here is a 1985 interview where she confided that she was in her second marriage " – the first was to a pianist, and a marriage between two artists is very difficult.  It was Carmen that liberated me from being the slave of the pianist."). 

Finally, the attractive repertoire, the marvelous voice and the beautiful accompaniment are splendidly put into relief by a remarkable recording. The LP sounds absolutely great. The voice is presented with beguiling fluidity and 'naturel'. The piano sounds as it should: 'metal and wood'. There's staggering dynamics in these grooves. And all this with a fairly simple Goldring Eroica. Admittedly, the soundstage is fairly compact and the stylus is not able to dig out the lowest frequencies. But that suits this kind of music fairly well. Whilst I certainly look forward to the day that I can listen to this with a more sophisticated element this LP has given me already much pleasure.

To end just two more quotes from the Bruce Duffy interview:
I like giving recitals because there is more light.  There is eye-contact between the singer and every member of the audience, even in a huge house with maybe 3000 people.  I’ve been giving recitals, and I am aware that way in the back there is one man who is not paying attention, who is not interested in what I am singing, and I can make him listen.  I can look at him and work on him (or her) until he’s awake.  More often, though, it is a “him.”  And, of course, when it is a “him,” it is easier to get him back.  [laughter]
I think that the kind of performances that are being offered to audiences nowadays is worse than it used to be.  I had an extraordinary stroke of luck that my career happened at the time that it did.  I began my career on the stage working with great conductors like Abbado and Giulini and Solti, and great stage-directors like Ponnelle and Zeffirelli.  This was a period when all the singers worked to create the very best possible performance of that music and the greatest possible theatrical portrayal of the characters, and this was arrived at because the rehearsal periods were a lot longer than they are now.  In the old days there used to be 25 days worth of rehearsals before the show took place, and during that time we worked very hard.  There were 4 or 5 rehearsals with orchestra plus a pre-dress rehearsal and a dress rehearsal.  So, with that kind of preparation, the performances came off in a way that is probably no longer possible.  Now, in the places where I go, the rehearsals are a week or 10 days before the show opens, and there are many singers who don’t even like to give that much!  They’d like to come a couple of days before the show, sing their performance, pick up their check and go on to the next city where they do the same thing again.  Since this is becoming more and more wide-spread as a practice, I believe that the performances being given nowadays are not of a quality that they used to be. 

maandag 29 augustus 2011

Sigur Ros: Takk ...

Following up on the Heima film, I listened to Sigur Ros' Takk ... , their fourth record (from 2005) and debut with music mogul EMI. Meanwhile I was taking care of a big pile of dishes. The 65 minute long CD stopped spinning just when I had cleared the last pots and pans from the sink. I must say it is not a burden to do the dishes whilst this kind of music spills from the speakers at a petrifying volume. One is carried away by an oceanic current into a liminal state. Takk ... is one giant, uninterrupted soundscape, often subdued and occasionally rising to blinding climaxes of distorted, sandpapery guitar clusters. It's unwise to want to sample individual tracks from such a work. You have to let it gush forward, in one whirl. I'm looking forward to the next pile of dishes (but I have to be alone in the house ...) 

zondag 28 augustus 2011

Comment - Auditing the hifi

Over the last couple of weeks I have been indulging in audiophile phantasising again. Truth of the matter is that I'm quite satisfied by what I'm hearing. But there is always a nagging doubt that significant improvement is possible at justifiable expense. Looking at my setup I am quite confident in the quality of my digital source. I think the Advanced Acoustic CD transport in combination with the Grace M902 DAC provides a very good quality input signal. The analogue source is another matter. The Michell Gyrodec is a solid basis, but I'm quite sure the Goldring Eroica MC element can be improved upon. Also the addition of an Orbe platter and an external power source are part of a clear upgrade path.

I have less confidence in the amplification stage. First there is the Promitheus Transformer Volume Control, which is in fact a passive preamp. It's a 350 euro 'sigar box', supposedly hand made in Malaysia. I bought it out of curiosity, but it has never left the setup ever since it replaced the Electrocompaniet ECM-5 preamp. Curiously enough it seems to perform well and to grow with subsequent improvements I have added to the setup. Nevertheless, the doubts come from the fact that this is a very cheap component, that the passive preamp concept is fairly controversial in itself (some people think it 'sucks the live out of the music') and that I have to live with the fact that I have very long (6 meter) interconnects to my power amps which sits uneasily with the passive concept. The big plus of a passive preamp is its transparancy and hence neutrality. It really doesn't colour the music.

The power amps are two Advance Acoustic M705 mono blocks that deliver 200 Watts at 8 Ohms. At less than 1.000 euros apiece they are not very expensive. I'm always wondering what they are really worth.

I am quite happy with the B&W 804s speakers but they are not the end of the line. At one point I'd like to buy something more substantial, with a little more oomph in the lower frequencies. The 802D would be a very nice 'rest of my lifetime' speaker but at 14.000 euro/pair this is very serious money. Not an investment I'm willing to contemplate right now.

I've upgraded my cablework over the last couple of years with serious Supra power cords, Supra interlinks, Link Velox speaker cable and Kimber Hero interconnects.

As this set has gradually grown into its present shape, I also wonder how coherent it is. Matching components is at least as important as having quality components to start with.

In addition to the amplification factor I am wondering about things like the quality of the net power, the placement of the components in the rack, the positioning of the speakers in the room, etc. How optimal is all of this? Are there tweaks that are able to bring audible improvement?

I have very little opportunity to compare notes with likeminded enthusiasts (I can count my audiophile friends on half a hand) and my reference framework of what is possible in the high end world is very limited. So, when I arrived on the website of a hifi-advisor/shop who indicated that he was willing to advise during home visits, I decided to take that opportunity and invite him in. My point was simply to ask a seasoned professional for a second opinion.

Today was the day. Audio Perfect's Peter Neirinck came by to have a listen and give some advice. He also brought some reference components to compare. I played him a few tracks of good recordings, both pop, chamber music, small ensemble and big orchestra. The verdict was very positive. He gave it a 9/10 calibrated against what is possible in the kind of price bracket I have been listening in and a 7,5/10 with 'high end ears' (where the sky is the limit in terms of budget). I thought that was a very good result. He admired the very clean, neutral, well-knit sound (in his opinion quite remarkable with the not so neutral B&W's), the set's responsiveness and the considerable depth of soundstage due to a very advantageous placement of the speakers with a huge, closed resonance box behind them. The power amps seemed to be more than adequate to drive the current-hungry speakers.

We then proceeded to compare with the Lyngdorf TDAI 2200 - an integrated digital amplifier - and the PS Audio Perfectwave CD transport. Add to that a very special speaker cable from Synergistic Research and you are talking about 10.000 euro worth of gear. The assessment was quite easy. First observation was that the sound of the Lyngdorf/PS Audio combo was very similar to the sound produced by my own setup. By and large we were listening to the same kind of neutral and clean picture. But it was also immediately clear that my own set provided more air, liquidity and authority to the music. It flowed more freely, providing a much more compelling listening experience. In a way it's not surprising giving that the Lyngdorf has an integrated amp and a DAC under one roof whilst in my case there are four components with equally many power sources. But the stiff price (4200 euro) of the Lyngdorf is a fact too.

So the conclusion is that I need to spend serious money to get a better sound, and even then it won't be a quantum leap. Putting 802Ds in the living room is going to make difference but it won't be a revolution. The analogue upgrade path is clear and that is certainly something I am going to do. For 2000 extre euros there is no doubt I can significantly improve the quality of my vinyl output. The digital chain will have to wait. I can't see me sinking 3000 euros or more into marginal improvements. Some kind of music server or streamer will eventually come, but the technology still needs to mature it seems to me. It's just an extra input channel. With the laptop and the iPad - complemented with a tweak to generate an asynchronous USB signal - I can go already a long way. All in all this is very good news. It has renewed my confidence in what I have built up over the years and brings, at least temporarily, peace of mind ...

Sigur Ros: Heima

Yesterday I watched a DVD devoted to a documentary film on Sigur Ros' 2006 Iceland tour. The band had been touring all over the world and when they came back to Iceland they added a string of 14 concerts in small cities and tiny villages all over the island. Heima ('home') blends live performanes, short interviews, and evocative nature stills into a surprisingly intimate, reflective whole. These are skillful musicians that are capable of producing something more than average pop drivel. It has taken me a long while to get into Sigur Ros, but as time goes by my appreciation waxes. I'm also intrigued by their way of working, which, as the film hints at, is very organic and also strikes me as very down-to-earth and authentic. I wonder when their 'indefinite hiatus' that started in 2008 will be suspended with new work. Soon a double live CD and film will be issued (Inni) but that too predates the hiatus. We wait with keen anticipation.

Mixed Arias by Mozart, Bizet and Verdi - Gershwin and jazz standards

Dutch Radio 4's Concerthuis has been another splendid discovery. I have listened to two full concerts via my iPad connected to the hifi setup. One was a gala concert from May this year with the soprano Anna Caterina Antonacci and the Rotterdam Philharmonic led by Christoph Ulrich Meier.  I was browsing the composer list looking for something short and familiar to listen to. Hitting Bizet brought me to this concert. The soloist wasn't familiar at all. A short snippet from Carmen, however, revealed a quite interesting voice, somewhere in between the soprano and mezzo range. I looked a few things up which revealed an artist with an unconventional career, spanning very different repertoires (from Renaissance to contemporary) and spending very little time in the recording studio (so small wonder I'd never heard of her). So I listened on, particularly enjoyed the Carmen pieces and the beautiful concluding aria from Verdi's Don Carlos. The RPO played very well, the sound from De Doelen concert hall was very good and the audience was disciplined but enthusiastic. Altogether an enjoyable listening experience, in its vibrant live ambience quite different from an average studio recording.

The other concert was even to a greater extent a case of serendipity. I wanted to check what was available under 'Bartok', but my finger selected 'Basie' instead. So I ended up with a performance of the Jazz Orchestra of the Concertgebouw, with pieces by Basie, Ellington and Gershwin, as well as a transcription of Tchaikovsky's Nutcracker Suite for large jazz ensemble. Same pattern here: I checked one of the shorter pieces and was sucked right in. Wow, this was a fantastic occasion with the orchestra playing their butts off. The Tchaikovsky was a good curtain raiser. Rudolf Brautigam was on the piano in a swinging version of  Gershwin's Rhapsody in Blue. I was captivated by the Basie and Ellington standards. Gershwin's I Got Rhtyhm was a rousing finale, with the orchestra under full steam. The sound from the Concertgebouw was astonishingly good, with the brass section cutting like laser beam through the musical fabric. It was a real treat. Clearly, the Concerthuis has a lot to offer.

Shostakovich: Chamber Symphony - Takemitsu: Requiem for Strings - Tchaikovsky: Symphony nr. 6

Another week without serious listening went by. Several reasons for that. Submitted my thesis on Monday and then had to throw myself headlong in three project that are running in parallel. So little time. Further, I am still exploring this whole streaming concept so I am reading up on it as much as I can, whilst trying out snippets here and there. With this, my interest in the audiophile side of the listening has again reared its ugly head, so I have been sampling a few things purely for comparative purposes. And, finally, I haven't settled down yet on what I would like to in the next few weeks. Shall I continue with the Bartok project which is still incomplete? What about the stack of string quartets that is waiting for me? Or maybe it is a better idea to relax and just hop between genres until I feel the gravitational pull from something or other?

Anyway, I do need to catch up on a few things I did listen to in the past few weeks. From the BP Digital Concert Hall I have not heard a lot yet. In fact I have limited myself to just one concert. A rather odd affair as it was a memorial concert on the occasion of 25 years Chernobyl (April 26, 1986) that brought together several ensembles in the Berliner Philharmonie: the strings of the Berlin Philharmonic, the Staatskapelle Berlin and a Ukrainian mixed chamber choir Credo.

The programme consisted of a long introductory part in which Shostakovich's Chamber Symphony op. 110a was played by the strings of the BPO, altercating with three pieces for choir, and then also texts declamated by two readers (Therese Affolter and Christian Brückner). The whole thing had a theatrical aspect with the strings arranged in a semi-circle (without conductor), backed by the speakers and choir. Despite the unconventional setup it was a gripping performance. The Chamber Symphony was brought with appropriate gravitas without sounding morose, the choir pieces were heartstoppingly beautiful and ravishingly sung and the speakers did quite well (particularly Affolter stood out).

After the break it was the Staatskapelle's turn, conducted by Andrei Boreyko. Allegedly it was his debut performance with the orchestra. I have one Boreyko CD in my collection: Schnittke's Faust Cantata complemented by Bach pieces (with the Hamburg Philharmonic, on Berlin Classics). He is known for enterprising programming. (Soon we will be able to hear more of that as the Belgian National Orchestra have been able to lure him as chief conductor from the 2012-13 season onwards. Next year, in April, he will make his Bozar debut. With Boreyko in Brussels and De Waart and Herreweghe in Antwerp it seems our orchestras are finally getting serious.) First there was a brief but beautiful piece, unbeknownst to me: the Requiem for Strings by Takemitsu. Up to this day I haven't quite fallen for Takemitsu's music which sounds like a somewhat diluted impressionism to me. But this early piece (1957) is very striking, almost Bartokian in the dark suppleness of its long lines. It put the young Japanese composer immediately on the map when it was (accidentally) auditioned by Stravinsky during one his visits to Tokyo. I thought the performance by the Staatskapelle was quite successful.

The concert was brought to a close by Tchaikovsky's "Pathétique". I was rather less impressed by this reading which didn't seem to plumb the depths of some of the others I know. Altogether a very unusual but well received concert on the DCH.


dinsdag 23 augustus 2011

Comment: Digital Concert Hall and streaming

Despite the dearth of serious music over the past few weeks, there have been momentous developments. It all started when I persuaded my parents to give me a full-year subscription to the Berlin Philharmonic's Digital Concert Hall. Earlier this year I had seen Rattle's take on Mahler's Resurrection live and was impressed by the quality of the whole concept. So now with a full year stretching out before me in which to see more than 100 archived concerts, 30 live concerts and a very nice collection of interviews and documentary films, I started to think earnestly about other options to listen to the music. My little AKG headset directly plugged into the MacBook is fine, but it would be nice to benefit of the full 320 kbps that is offered by the Berliner.

The solution was surprisingly simple. I just had to connect my computer via a USB A to mini-B cable to my Grace M902 DAC and that was it. Beautiful streaming sound through my B&W 804s! I was captivated. Suddenly a host of new opportunities suggested themselves. What about digital transmissions from classical radio station? And indeed, I soon found the Concerthuis by Dutch Radio 4 and could listen to their archived collection of more than 100 live concerts. Fantastic! Same with France Musique, Arte TV, and so on.

Given that the M902 functions as a high quality headphone amp, there was no problem at all to listen to the performances via the splendid Beyerdynamic T1. Quite a difference with the AKG!

Then onwards to the iPad. Same kind of connection via the USB cable to the Grace and I could watch the Berliner on this flimsy, shiny disc whilst listening to great sound. Wow! I was over the moon, feeling like a little boy with too much money in the candy store. The sheer volume of music you can just tune into is amazing.

In terms of quality of sound, I like what I hear. The concerts by the Berliner are of stellar quality. I can't hear the difference with a good (!) CD. But even the Concerthuis seems to transmit at a very decent quality. It's probably only 128 kbps but I can't really hear it. I do hear the compromises in quality though when listening to the 15 minute previews of the Naxos Musical Library. That is an amazing phenomenon that I didn't even know existed. It's a library that gives access to more than 50.000 CDs from many 'smaller' labels (meaning not Universal Music), including Naxos itself, but also Chandos, BIS, Da Capo, ZigZag, BBC Legends etc. It's simply intimidating. All that becomes accessible at 128 kpbs for 220 euro/year. I think this is an amazing offer. I haven't perused it yet, but I may do so in the future, even if only for research purposes. For now I have more than enough to listen to.

Likely there are improvements possible in terms of sound quality. Whether the quality of the USB cable makes a difference is a matter of debate. Some say it doesn't and others (like Wim Vanderstraeten from Link) say it does. I am not planning to invest in a high end cable for the time being. The other thing is that the Grace is a very good DAC but the USB transfer mode is synchronous which allegedly is not the best for audio. The M902 is, however, not able to do this. The new M903 is, but there is no upgrade path from one to the other. Oh well, so be it. For the time being I'll stick to what I have.

Another thing which becomes a realistic option now is to start playing music from hard disk. I have an acute space problem when it comes to CDs and I might put certain parts of my collection (pop music, to start with) on a hard drive to listen to. I have been reading up on the Bryston BDP-1 which seems like an eminently sensible concept to me: it's just a reader. Storage and DAC remain outboard which should improve the quality of the whole setup.

I haven't been listening a lot to any of the new music sources. Lack of time, to an extent. But there is also the strange psychological mechanism that the more abundant the music resources are I have access to, the more circumspect I become in using them. I really do not want to fall into the trap of consumptive listening, but want to give whatever I listen to adequate time and attention. Maybe I am getting too worked up about it all, but that's the way I am feeling about it. To be continued ...



Holiday Pop Medley

 Holiday, at least whilst being on the road, is more a time for casual listening. As last year I blindly bought a stack of pop CDs to entertain us while we were away. The highlight from the previous crop was The National's High Violet, a sterling disc that catapulted the band high on my list of favourites.

This year I hit the bull's eye with Mumford & Sons' Sigh No More (which is this London band's first and as yet only album). In fact, my son (who is otherwise not very much in to music) had brought it already last year to my attention, but I left it, at full price. Now, at a mere 5 euros it was a no-brainer. I thoroughly love M&S's brawny kind of folk rock (or country rock). The songs are raw and relatively uncouth but they are really well composed, full of interesting twists and turns. This is more than just packaging some nice tunes. There's not a weak point in the whole album. But pressed I'd single out White Blank Page, Little Lion Man and Thistle and Weeds as highlights.

Scott Matthew (not Matthews, who is someone else) is an Australian singer-songwriter I hadn't heard about. His Gallantry's Favourite Song is, however, a very atmospheric and intelligent album that has given me considerable pleasure. The music comes across as very simple and straightforward, wrapped in sober acoustic arrangements. But it is surprisingly subtle. I am particularly struck by the harmonic niceties that are woven into the music. As a result it sounds more playful and urbane than Bon Iver's For Emma, for example. And Matthew's distinctive, nasal voice does the rest to keep the listener spellbound. The nocturnal phantasy True Sting is no doubt the absolute highlight of the album. Very nice artwork too, by the way, with mysterious pictures shot in some Corsican palazzo.

Talking about Bon Iver, I also bought his much anticipated second album, with the rather uninspiring title Bon Iver, Bon Iver. This was a bit of a downer. For my taste this sounded a little bit all over the place. It misses the coherence and the winter sky transparency of the debut album. I could live with the too clever, top heavy arrangements and the kitchy reverberance if the songs were truly distinguished. But they aren't. It's all rather flat and clichéd and sometimes outright irritating. Even in scattered highlights such as Michicant and Wash there is atmosphere but too little substance. We'll hope for better next time.

PJ Harvey, then. An album she co-wrote with John Parish in 2009: A Woman A Man Walked by. This is PJ at its wildest and wackiest. Not for the faint-hearted. Scatological lyrics wrapped in punkish extravaganzas. But somehow it speaks of real artistry. The more I listen to it, the better it gets. It's much, much better than her latest, the rather phony Let England Shake (also with JP, by the way). This may end up there with Is This Desire and To Bring You My Love.

Three more to go. Johnny Cash's last recording before he passed away is a nice collection of wistful songs of the ageing, tired American bard. I listened most often to his moving take on Gordon Lightfoot's classic If You Could Read My Mind.

Elbow's Sleep in the Dark was their debut, in 2001. I have it already since last year. But now the album really hit me. It's a fantastic collection that doesn't have to stand in the shadow of its more popular successors. Perhaps a little more hard-bitten than what was to follow, it provides solid, rowdy listening pleasure. Highlight certainly is Newborn, which starts like a hymnic ballad and after 2 minutes morphs into a darkly obsessive extemporation, stretching the song well into the 7 minutes.

A few years ago someone mentioned Mogwai to me. 'Wall of Sound', he said. I never came round to listening to it. But now I was seduced by the nice urban photography that graces the cover of their latest album with the rather sophomoric title Hardcore Will Never Die, But You Will. Someone else said: 'Post-rock, like Sigur Ros, but without the fairy tale element." Maybe, but give me Sigur Ros any time. I don't think Mogwai delivers the goods. I love the broad soundscapes but then again it's all surface and little meat. At least I haven't been able to detect up to now. It's not terribly well recorded to boot. This is, in fact, a double album including a bonus CD with 25 minutes of music for the film 'Monument for a Forgotten Future' (again that bombast). I'd have to give it a little bit more time, but it seems to me the bonus might be the thing that draws me back to this music. We'll see.

Shostakovich: String Quartet nr. 7

I'm happy to be pick up the thread again after a long spell. That interval is partly due to the holiday period and partly to the fact that I had to dig in to write my masterpaper for the urban planning program. That's now just been submitted and now we can free up some space in our mind for other things.

I haven't been doing any serious listening over that past period. The only little thing I have to mention is a short Shostakovich quartet (at about 15 minutes the Seventh is, in fact, his shortest) in a 1990 recording from Snape Maltings concert hall. Excellent reading of a typical piece of the mature Shostakovich, mixing brutal violence with a wry kind of simplicity.